Dublin: 4 °C Wednesday 24 April, 2024
great debate

Real Christmas tree v fake Christmas tree - we decide

O Christmas tree….


Over the next few days thousands of people across the country will mobilise to fulfil the Christmas tree tradition.

We’ve come up with an arbitrary yet definitive scoring system to determine one of the great Christmas questions:



This is a category where the real tree really comes into its own. You can light all the candles and spray all the sprays you want, but nothing will ever beat the festive stank of a noble fir in the corner of the sitting room.


Fake tree Christmas points: 1

Real tree Christmas points: 10

Cost effectiveness

While an artificial tree might cost you more in terms of a one-off payment (€100+ if you’re going for the real good stuff), it will stand to you in the long run, as you smugly wheel it out in subsequent years while your Visa Debit stays firmly in you wallet.

A real tree on the other hand will set you back around €50, and is already dying as you hand over the cash.

Harvesting Christmas Trees Laura Hutton / Photocall Ireland Laura Hutton / Photocall Ireland / Photocall Ireland

Fake tree Christmas points: 8

Real tree Christmas points: 3


Artificial trees have come on in leaps and bounds, affording the buyer the perfect balance between aesthetically pleasing triangle, and just enough wonky branches to give it character.

Finding a perfectly shaped real tree on the other hand is akin to laying your hands on the good scissors at the precise moment you need them, ie impossible.

15_worst_xmas_photos_08 Printing-cdn Printing-cdn

Fake tree Christmas points: 7

Real tree Christmas points: 4


Shape and personality go hand in hand, and while your real Christmas tree might be more like a Christmas bush, with an inexplicable bald three foot branch protruding from the top, at least it’s got Christmas magic. The things it must have seen!

5Af5gYN Imgur Imgur

Fake trees meanwhile, are magic vacuums.

Fake tree Christmas points: 1

Real tree Christmas points: 13


Artificial trees come with built in stands. They are ergonomically sound. They were designed with stability in mind.

A real tree will leave you close to tears as you attempt to seduce the trunk into whatever newfangled stand you’ve been conned into purchasing. And often, even looking at it wrong may cause it to pitch sideways, flinging baubles about the room. If you have an inquisitive cat… forget about it.

Every year he's amazed when we bring in the Christmas tree Imgur Imgur

Fake tree Christmas points: 11

Real tree Christmas points: 2


No contest.

christmas-tree-carpet-mess Netdna-cdn Netdna-cdn

Fake tree Christmas points: 10

Real tree Christmas points: 1


Buying a real Christmas tree in a pot places you in the best of both worlds. You maintain that Christmas magic while also ensuring that your only storage/disposal worries are dragging it outside to grow for another 12  months (assuming that you can manage to keep it alive until next Christmas).

Other real trees come with the headache of disposal come the grim grey days of January, while artificial trees require disassembly and storage. Nobody’s a winner.

Screw it, this is how we're taking down our fake Christmas tree this year Imgur Imgur

Fake tree Christmas points: 5

Real tree Christmas points: 5


For many, the yearly tradition of picking and buying a real tree is a magical family memory. Dragging the artificial one down out of the attic with some baubles still attached just doesn’t hold the same wonder.

Collection Christmas Trees Laura Hutton / Photocall Ireland Laura Hutton / Photocall Ireland / Photocall Ireland

Fake tree Christmas points: 2

Real tree Christmas points: 15

And the winner is… the real Christmas tree, with 53 points to 45.


Where do you stand? 

Poll Results:

Real (4258)
Fake (4152)
I Don't Care (654)

6 abandoned Christmas trees that just wanted to be loved

Poll: Have you put up your Christmas tree?

Council officials teach town a lesson after complaints over crap Christmas tree

Your Voice
Readers Comments
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.